Your Spare Tire Buying Guide: What Drivers Need to Know

A flat tire can turn a normal day into a stressful one, especially if you discover your spare is missing, worn down, or not the right fit for your car. Having a reliable spare tire on hand gives drivers the confidence to handle the unexpected and get back on the road safely. Whether you're replacing an old spare, preparing for a long drive, or simply making sure your vehicle is equipped, knowing what to look for can make a significant difference.

Below, we break down what drivers need to know when shopping for a spare tire—plus how the lease-to-own option may help you stay prepared without straining your wallet.

How To Choose a Spare Tire

Choosing the right spares starts with understanding what your vehicle needs and how you plan to use it. Many drivers assume all spares are interchangeable, which leads to the common question: Are spare tires universal? But they aren’t. 

Before you make a purchase, it's helpful to understand the key differences in size, fit, and durability, so you can make a confident decision.

Tire Size

Choosing the right spare also depends on the size and type of tire your vehicle can safely support. Most drivers will choose from a few standard spare types, each designed for different needs and space considerations.

• Full-Size Matching Spare: A full-size spare matches your regular tires and allows normal driving until you fix or replace the damaged one.
• Compact Temporary Spare (“Donut”): A compact spare is lighter and smaller to save trunk space and weight, but it’s only intended for short distances and lower speeds.

Driving Conditions

The environment you drive in can influence the type of spare tire you choose:

• Drivers who regularly travel long distances or through rural areas with limited service may want to consider a full-size spare for greater stability and longer driving capability. 
• City drivers who stay close to repair shops and typically encounter shorter trips can often rely on a compact or temporary spare but should fix or replace the regular tire as soon as possible. 
• Drivers who frequently face harsh weather, unpaved roads, or long commutes might choose a more durable spare for added peace of mind and reduced risk when a flat occurs.

How To Put a Spare on Your Vehicle

Knowing how to replace a spare tire can help you stay prepared while you wait for roadside assistance or handle the swap yourself. Refer to your owner’s manual for step-by-step instructions for replacing a tire on your vehicle.

After installing a spare, avoid high speeds and long distances until it can be replaced properly. If you’ve been putting off checking your spare, take this as a sign it may be time for new tires—including your emergency backup.

How Much Does a Spare Tire Cost?

Prices depend on the type of spare you choose. Here’s a general breakdown of typical price ranges:

• Full-Size Spare: Usually ranges from $100 to $350+, depending on tire brand, size, and tread style. It will typically be the same price as the tires already on your car.
• Compact/Donut Spare: Typically costs $50 to $200+, making it the most budget-friendly option.

Where Can I Buy a Spare Tire?

You can shop for spare tires at almost any tire store, auto repair center, dealership, or nationwide retailer that carries vehicle parts. However, not every retailer offers flexible ways to get the essentials you need when an unexpected automotive purchase comes your way. That’s where lease-to-own can make a meaningful difference. 

When you shop through participating retailers that offer the lease-to-own option from Acima Leasing at checkout, you can take home the spare tire you need now with easy lease payment options. There’s no upfront large expense, which can be especially helpful when a flat tire disrupts your day or forces an unplanned purchase.

Find the Right Tire with Acima Leasing Near You

Stay prepared with a reliable spare tire. Acima Leasing makes it easy to get the tires you need now. Shop and apply with our trusted tire partners and take advantage of the lease-to-own option designed to keep you on the road with peace of mind. You can also download the Acima app for Apple and Android for an even more convenient shopping experience.